|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Catholic Devotion To the Virgin Mary |
 |
And what about the
moving lips during a silent recitation of
the Rosary? There is nothing wrong with
honoring the Mother of God, or is there?
Of course not. Mary IS
the Mother of God. Some might argue that the
rosary is not Bible-based, especially it is
a devotion to someone not biblical. Some
might even argue that the rosary is a
hindrance to
|
|
ecumenism. I can offer you opinions but I’d
much rather go by the words
of an expert.
In his book, Nuts &
Bolts, Basilica Press, 1999, Tim Staples, a
former Assemblies of God youth pastor who is
a convert to the Catholic Church, relates a
situation wherein a defense of the devotion
to the Virgin Mary was called for.
Basically, the arguments against the Virgin
Mary come in three stipulations:
-
Nowhere in
Scripture do we find the words, "Mother
of God" used to describe Mary
-
Luke 1:43
(the account on the
visitation of Mary to her cousin
Elizabeth) seems to be the only verse in
Scripture that Catholics use to support
their claim, where Elizabeth calls Mary,
"mother of my Lord," and not the mother
of God.
-
It would be
impossible for God have a mother. If the
Catholic teaching is true, then since
God is Trinity, then Mary is the Mother
of the Trinity.
|
|
Continued below... |
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
My Prayer Box
Newsletter |
|
|
My Prayer Box newsletter is published weekly and contains the
readings for that Sunday. It has reflections, stories and
reader contributions, prayers and news relevant to living a
proud Catholic life.
The reader contributions include announcements, interesting
articles, pictures and greetings. We also solicit news
regarding activities and events your parishes that you might
useful for others.
The newsletter has over 1000 subscribers.
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
Tim Staples then laid out the counter
arguments supporting the Catholic teaching
as follows:
-
"Mother of God" term to describe Mary is
non-biblical, would also exclude the use
of the Trinity, simply because it is not
in the Holy Writ either. The question
then to ask is: "Is the concept of Mary,
the Mother of God, taught in Sacred
Scripture?"
-
Mary is "mother of my Lord," and not the
mother of God. The title "Lord," is a
title of divinity for Jesus in the New
Testament. In
1 Corinthians 8:5 the term Lord was
not used to refer to divinity, however,
the very next verse says: "Yet to us
there is one God, the Father, from whom
are all things and through whom we
exist." These verses clearly connection
between Jesus the "Lord" and His being
creator of all things.
John 1:1-3 also connects Jesus as
"God" to His being the Creator of all
things: "In the beginning was the Word,
and the Word was with god, and the Word
was God. He was in the beginning with
God; all things were made through him,
and without him was not anything made
that was made." Other Biblical
references to the "Lord" referring to
the divinity of Jesus:
Genesis 1:1; and also,
Mark 2:28: "So the Son of man is
lord even of the Sabbath."
In the
Catechism of the Catholic Church,
paragraph 495, the Catholic Church
says that Mary is the Mother of God
precisely because Jesus Christ, her Son,
is Himself God.
-
If Virgin Mary is the Mother of God,
then Mary would also be the Mother of
the Trinity: All these arguments can
wrap up into one: the Incarnation. If
Jesus was born of the Virgin Mary and
Jesus is God, then it follows that the
Virgin Mary IS the Mother of God. If
Jesus IS lord and NOT God, then we are
talking about two persons: one, the
human Jesus, son of Mary and the other
the divine Jesus with no Mother. The
Catholic Church teaches that Mary is the
Mother of the second Person of the Holy
Trinity, by virtue of the Incarnation.
The Father and the Holy Spirit were NOT
incarnated. Mary is NOT the source of
the divine nature of the second Person
of the Trinity – she is not the source
of the soul – God is. Christ’s divine
nature didn’t change in the Incarnation
(Malachi 3:6,
Numbers 23:19;
James 1:17). Christ’s human and
divine natures were completely united in
the Incarnation, and Mary gave birth to
this divine Person.
And why do Catholics offer devotions to
Mary? Precisely because Mary is the Mother
of God. See the
Catechism of the Catholic Church, Article 3
"He was Conceived by the Power of the
Holy Spirit, and was Born of the Virgin
Mary." Note: The biblical references are
very important. Not that you will need them
but these can come in very handy if pressed
for proof of the Mary being the Mother of
God. |
| |
|
| |
So what's next?
When most people think
of Bible-Christians, they usually mean those
in the Protestant denominations. They "own"
the Bible, right? And the Church really does
not want us to read the bible, right again?
Well, wrong. Nothing could be further from
the truth.
|
| |
|
| |
You will
have to wait for the next issues! Note: This series of
articles on Catholic Apologetics are based on research
from several books. I really encourage you to read at
least the following:
-
1What
Catholics Really Believe-Setting the Record Straight: 52
Answers to Common Misconceptions About the Catholic
Faith
,
Ignatius Press, San Francisco, 1992, by Karl Keating,
director Catholic Answers, a lay-run apologetics
and evangelization organization, and editor of the
magazine, This Rock. He is also the author of the
best-seller, Catholicism and Fundamentalism.
-
2 Nuts
& Bolts: A Practical Guide for Explaining and Defending
the Catholic Faith ,
Basilica Press, San Diego, 1999, by Tim Staples, a
former Assemblies of God youth pastor who converted to
the Catholic Church.
-
3Catholic
Source Book
,
Harcourt Religion Publishers, 2000, by Rev. Peter Klein.
Rev Peter Klein is a priest of the Diocese of Winona in
Minnesota.
-
4Our
Sunday Visitor's Catholic Encyclopedia
,
Our Sunday Visitor Publishing Division, Huntington,
Indiana, 1998, by Rev. Peter M.J. Stravinskas, editor.
Rev. Peter M.J. Stravinskas is the author of eleven
books and more than 500 articles. He is the founding
editor of Catholic Answer and the administrator
of St. John the Baptist Church of Bayonne, New Jersey.
He likewise serves as adjunct professor of education at
Seton Hall University in South Orange, New Jersey.
|
| |
To read the rest of the series on Catholic Apologetics,
please select one of the links below.
Apologetics Part 1:
Catholic Practices and Traditions - Be Proud of Them
Apologetics Part 2: Catholic
Devotion To the Virgin Mary
Apologetics Part 3: Bible Catholics?
Apologetics Part 4: The Catholic
Beliefs Are Not Found in the Bible
Apologetics Part 5: Everything the
Pope Says is Infallible
Apologetics Part 6: Catholics Are
Not Born-Again - So They Are Not Saved
Apologetics Part 7: Catholics
Worship Saints, Icons and Statues
Apologetics Part 8: Anointing the
Sick with Holy Oil
Did
You Know?
Priestly Celibacy Is A Disciplinary
Rule and not a Doctrine
Did
You Know?
That criticism of the Catholic
Church comes from both the right and the left
Non-Catholic Criticism:
Indulgences: A Catholic Can Buy Salvation
Non-Catholic Criticism:
Communion of Saints
- Why Catholics believe in Saints
Non-Catholic Criticism:
Call No One on Earth Your Father
|
| |
|
|
|
Apologetics |
 |
Mary
and the Saints |
 |
Mass
and the Eucharist |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Prayers |
 |
Novenas |
 |
The Rosary |
 |
Traditional Prayers:
Discover the origin of your favorite prayer. We might
even have the original Latin version, too. |
|
|
 |
Novenas: Learn how
to say a novena in honor of your favorite
Saint.
|
|
|
|
|
Archived Articles |
 |
Prayer Requests |
 |
Tours and Pilgrimages |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|